I’m a total eyeliner girl.  I love playing around with different brands, and lately I’ve been on a quest to find the perfect pencil eyeliner.  I already love powders – they can be dampened and brushed on for vibrant color – but finding a nice, not-too-pricey pencil liner that goes on smoothly and lasts all day is what I would like to find.

Enter Pencil Me In Cosmetics.  Everything on their site intrigued me – their models have gorgeous eyes, their shade selection is awesome, and their pencils uniquely feature:

  • All-natural ingredients, clinically tested
  • Anti-oxidants and vitamins to keep the eye area soft and smooth
  • A built-in sharpener in each pencil cap
  • Smooth, creamy application that doesn’t pull on delicate eye skin

So I wrote to them, and they sent me a few shades to test for myself!  I requested these three shades: Buff, Nutmeg, and Liberty Green (shown below in that order).

What I Like: They go on smoothly, and have a lovely creamy texture!  The sharpener in the cap is so nice and convenient.  The color lasts all day.  And the shades are beautiful! The fact that they are all-natural is a huge plus for me, too.

What I don’t like: My only problem with the pencils is that the shades I chose don’t go on quite as dark as I would like, even with multiple layers.  Also, it’s hard to create a fine, thin line with the creamy texture and size of the pencils.

Overall, I’m very pleased with these pencils – the cons I listed above would not stop me from ordering a few more pencils and collecting some darker shades that will show up more vibrantly, and the colors I chose are great if you want to layer coordinating shades.

My thoughts on the “Buff” Pencil: This is actually not an eyeliner shade meant to be put on by itself, but an accent pencil.  According to the Pencil Me In Website, it has a “creamy pale green hue color which can counteract redness giving the illusion of a bigger brighter wider eye.” I’m a worn out mom who deals with trying to cover up tired, red eyes on a daily basis, so I was thrilled to give it a try.  And I’m happy to be able to tell you that I was pleased with the result!  It truly does help to cover up the red around your eyes, and prepares them for application of your regular eyeliner.  This is a product I love!

Buy it! (And Deal Alert!)

Each pencil is $6.99, and Pencil Me In Cosmetics always has some great deals going on.  Right now, they are offering:

Buy 2, Get 1 Free
Buy 4, Get 2 Free
and so on!

To take advantage of this great promotion, follow these directions:

Log onto www.pencilmeincosmetics.com and choose the pencil colors that you would like to purchase.  Then proceed to the shopping cart page. On the shopping cart page, you will see in purple a link for this promotion. Click on it.  The user name and password for this section is the same word:  “Healthy”  Choose your free pencils and proceed to check out!

You can also find the Pencil Me In Cosmetics line in professional beauty salons, spas, upscale cosmetic boutiques.

Email Newsletter: Sign up for their email newsletter for sale announcements, make-up tips, and more!

I would like to thank Pencil Me In Cosmetics for sending me the products reviewed above so that I could share my experiences with you!  This review is my own opinion and was not edited or reviewed by anyone.


One Response to Pencil Me In Cosmetics – Natural Eyeliner Review

  • It’s actually a nice and helpful piece of information.
    I’m satisfied that you just shared this useful information with us.
    Please stay us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up for updates and freebies!

More from Kindred Spirit Mommy
Must Read!